Dementia Care: Walk-In Tub Versus Walk-In Shower for Person with Dementia

Walk in tub or walk in shower?

Understanding Dementia and Its Impact

Dementia is a complex and multifaceted condition that affects not only the individual but also their loved ones and caregivers. It is essential to understand the impact of dementia on daily life, relationships, and overall well-being. Dementia symptoms can vary widely, but common effects include memory loss, confusion, difficulty with communication, and changes in mood and behavior. As the condition progresses, individuals with dementia may require increasing levels of support and care.

It is crucial to recognize that dementia is not a single disease, but rather a collection of symptoms caused by various underlying conditions, such as Alzheimer’s disease, vascular dementia, and mixed dementia. Understanding the specific type of dementia and its progression can help caregivers and family members provide more effective support and care.

Here's more information for you ...

How to Bath Without a Battle

I use lemon scented face cloths when I want to lift the spirits or encourage them to be more alert. Of course, providing a warm soapy washcloth to wash hands before meals and after toileting. If your family member with dementia enjoys playing in water, give them a pan of warm soapy water, and let them soak their hands. Take time to dry the hands and do nail care. You can do the same with their feet.

If they will allow you to put their feet in a foot bath, or warm water soak their feet, do their nails, if you can. I recommend that you see if there is a home visiting podiatrist is available in your neighborhood. That can help you with managing the toe nails.

When your family member changes their clothes, or uses the toilet, this is your opportunity to provide intimate care. Remember, make it comfortable and use warm cloths. When they are sitting on the toilet, you can change tops, and wash under arms and put on deodorant. Wash between their legs, or ask them to do, it they are still able to follow directions. Additionally, consider utilizing respite care services to give yourself a break and ensure your loved one receives the care they need.

Walk in Tub versus Walk In Shower

As an RN, I have been to many different memory care units. Some very high-end Assisted Living programs with memory care units have invested in very nice walk-in showers. The walk-in tubs located in these memory care units do not get used. Persons with dementia would find it difficult to sit in while waiting for the water to fill the tub. Many have an irrational fear of small spaces.

For individuals with mild cognitive impairment, early adaptations in the bathroom can help ease the transition as their condition progresses.

Even a walk-in shower can be challenging when bathing a person with dementia. I have a family that told me, they cannot get their mother in the shower and this has been a challenge for over a year.

Walk in shower you can roll a shower chair in

Many seniors, even those with dementia, have a fear of falling and do not want to get into a shower. I recommend that you ask for a home safety evaluation done by a physical or occupational therapist. This is done through a Medicare-certified home care agency. This evaluation for home safety needs an order from your doctor.

The home safety evaluation can help you determine where to place grab bars or make your tub, or walk-in shower safe to use. They can recommend a shower chair or a potty chair that will be able to use in the shower, or bathtub. This will depend on the home, and the space available.

If you are going to make home modifications, you may want to consult with a certified aging in place specialist. They can help you determine what changes can be made within your needs and budget.

I am also going to give you one more consideration to think about when you are discussing walk-in tubs versus walk-in showers. As a person with dementia progresses through the disease process, they will become incontinent of bowel and bladder. Using a walk-in tub will make cleaning your family member if they become incontinent while bathing. They will be left to sit in dirty water, as you wait for the water to empty out.

Walk in tubs have so many benefits to aging seniors with mild cognitive impairment.

A walk in shower can be as difficult to get a person with dementia in, as a walk in tub. The thing is, bathing can be a challenge, and you may go long periods of time, when you may not get them to go into any type of walk in shower, or walk in bathtub. That is when you, as a caregiver, must adjust to providing care in bits and pieces. Making sure you lotion the skin, to keep it hydrated. Choose your battles wisely. There are many challenges you will face as a caregiver daily. Maintaining a healthy diet is also crucial for overall well-being and can help manage some symptoms of dementia.

Thank you for this great question. Please feel free to contact me with any other questions. I encourage other caregivers to share what they do to provide care.

Safety and Accessibility in the Bathroom

The bathroom can be a hazardous place for individuals with dementia, particularly as the condition progresses. Safety and accessibility are critical considerations to prevent accidents and injuries. Here are some tips to create a safer and more accessible bathroom:

• Install Grab Bars and Non-Slip Mats: These can help prevent falls and provide support.
• Use a Shower Chair or Bench: This provides stability and balance during bathing.
• Ensure Good Lighting: A well-lit bathroom reduces the risk of accidents.
• Keep the Bathroom Clutter-Free: Remove unnecessary items to create a clear path.
• Use a Toilet Seat Riser: An elevated toilet seat can make it easier for individuals to use the toilet.
• Consider a Walk-In Shower or Tub: These can be safer and more accessible options for bathing.

Designing a Dementia-Friendly Bathroom

Designing a dementia-friendly bathroom requires careful consideration of the individual’s needs and abilities. Here are some tips to create a bathroom that is both safe and accessible:

• Simple and Clear Signage: Use signs to clearly identify the bathroom and its facilities.
• Calming Color Scheme: Choose colors that are soothing and easy to navigate.
• Easy-to-Use Mirror: Install a mirror that provides a clear view and is easy to use.
• Accessible Sink and Faucet: Ensure the sink and faucet are easy to operate.
• Bathroom Alarm System: Consider installing an alarm system to alert caregivers in case of an emergency.

Here are a few Expert Tips for Ensuring a Comfortable and Successful Shower or Bath for People with Dementia

Bathing can be a challenge when caring for someone with dementia. While some individuals may not mind it, others may show fear and resistance. Understanding the causes and implementing these tips can make bath time easier for both the individual and the caregiver.

Establishing a consistent routine during the early stages of dementia can help make bath time more manageable as the condition progresses.

Make a spa like environment

Causes of Challenging Behaviors in Bathing:

Embarrassment: Privacy concerns can make bathing with someone else present uncomfortable and embarrassing.

Fear of Water: Traumatic incidents or anxiety can lead to a fear of water, especially showers for those accustomed to baths.

Lack of Understanding: Middle or later stage dementia can cause confusion and resistance due to not understanding the purpose of bathing. Family counseling can also provide valuable support and strategies for managing these challenging behaviors.

Tips to Improve Bath Time: Maintain Eye Contact

Prepare in Advance: Have soap, shampoo, and a warm towel ready to ensure a smooth process.

Offer a Choice: Provide the option between a bath or a shower, considering the individual’s preferences and comfort level.

Adjust the Time of Day: Honor the person’s routine by finding out their preferred bathing time and stick to it.

Establish a Routine: Follow a consistent routine and consider having the same caregiver to maintain familiarity and comfort.

Ensure a Warm Room Temperature: Make sure the bathing environment is comfortable by keeping the room warm.

Encourage Independence: If possible, allow the person to wash themselves for a sense of dignity and empowerment.

Consider Same-Sex Caregiver: If privacy or inappropriate behavior is a concern, offer a caregiver of the same sex.

Provide Privacy and Comfort: Offer large bath towels or shower capes to enhance privacy and warmth.

Set the Tone with Music: Play preferred music to create a soothing atmosphere and potentially engage the individual.

Address Pain Relief: Consult with a physician to manage pain that may be contributing to resistance towards bathing.

Use Humor: Employ humor as a tool to reduce anxiety, increase comfort, and distract from the task at hand.

Create a Spa-Like Atmosphere: Enhance the environment by adding art, music, and even a towel heater to improve comfort.

Mention Doctor’s Orders: Remind the individual that their doctor has recommended bathing, redirecting any frustration towards the physician.

Consider No-Rinse Products: Use no-rinse soap and shampoo to shorten the bathing process and reduce anxiety.

Choose Different Words: Use alternative phrases like “washing up” or “getting ready for the day” to appeal to individuals who may react negatively to specific words.

Seek Professional Help: Consider hiring an experienced home healthcare aide for a more comfortable and effective bathing experience.

Try Different Family Members: If one family member encounters resistance, another family member may succeed in assisting with bathing.

Sponge Bathing as an Alternative: If all else fails, consider sponge bathing as a compromise to still achieve cleanliness and hygiene.

By implementing these strategies, bath time can be a more positive and manageable experience for both individuals with dementia and their caregivers. Joining an online community can also provide valuable support and advice from others who are facing similar challenges.

FAQ: Dementia Care – Walk-In Shower vs. Walk-In Tub

How do I decide between a walk-in shower or a walk-in tub for a person with dementia or Alzheimer’s disease?
A: When making this decision, consider dementia symptoms such as memory loss, confusion, and difficulty with thinking skills. Walk-in showers may be safer for people with dementia due to easier access and fewer tripping hazards. However, a walk-in tub can be helpful if the person enjoys baths for relaxation, which can reduce feelings of depression and anxiety. Family counseling and input from other family members can help in the decision-making process.

What are the safety benefits of a walk-in shower for people living with dementia?
A: A walk-in shower is often safer for people with mild cognitive impairment and other dementias because it reduces the risk of falls. Features such as grab bars, non-slip floors, and a handheld showerhead can improve safety. Caregivers should maintain eye contact and offer reassurance during bathing to ease anxiety.

Can a walk-in tub benefit someone with Alzheimer's disease or other conditions that cause memory loss?
A: Yes, walk-in tubs with temperature controls can prevent burns and provide therapeutic benefits, such as soothing sore muscles. The warm water can help with relaxation, improving sleep and reducing symptoms of agitation common in dementia. However, it is essential to ensure the person can manage the locking mechanism or have a caregiver assist them.

What other risk factors should be considered when choosing between a walk-in shower and a walk-in tub?
A: Consider risk factors such as the person's mobility, balance issues, and stage of dementia. In the early stages of Alzheimer’s or other dementias, a walk-in tub may be manageable, but as symptoms worsen, a walk-in shower may become more practical. Also, consider the future progression of the disease and the person's ability to carry out daily activities.

How can I involve family members in the decision-making process?
A: Hold a family meeting or seek family counseling to discuss the person's needs and preferences. An online community or local support group can also offer valuable insights from other caregivers. Involving the family ensures everyone is on the same page and provides emotional support during this decision.

Should I consult a doctor or other healthcare professionals before deciding?
A: Yes, consulting the person’s doctor, occupational therapist, or dementia care specialist can help assess the person’s abilities and recommend suitable options. They can also address other conditions that may impact bathing safety, such as arthritis or severe mobility issues.

How can I create a safe environment for bathing with either option?
A:

• For Walk-In Showers: Install grab bars, non-slip mats, and a shower seat. Maintain eye contact and offer reassurance during the bath.
• For Walk-In Tubs: Ensure the water temperature is safe, and the door locks securely. Stay nearby to help if needed.

In both cases, keep the bathroom warm and well-lit to reduce confusion and discomfort.

How can I help my loved one with dementia feel comfortable during bath time?
A: Use clear communication, maintain eye contact, and offer reassurance throughout the bathing process. Play soft music or involve a friend or familiar caregiver to create a calming environment. Respect their privacy and feelings while ensuring their safety.

Can a healthy diet and regular exercise reduce the need for specialized bathing equipment?
A: While a healthy diet and regular exercise support brain health and may slow cognitive decline, they do not eliminate the need for safe bathing solutions. However, they can help maintain mobility and independence for a longer time, making a walk-in shower a more viable long-term option.

Where can I find support or advice on making this decision?
A: Join an online community or local dementia support group to connect with caregivers who have faced similar decisions. Participate in upcoming events, webinars, or educational workshops offered by dementia care organizations to gain more knowledge about creating a safe home environment.

Final Thoughts:
Whether you choose a walk-in shower or a walk-in tub, the goal is to support your loved one’s safety, comfort, and dignity. As dementia progresses, the person’s needs will change, and caregivers should remain flexible and ready to adapt the home environment. Seek advice from professionals, involve family members, and prioritize the person’s well-being throughout the decision-making process.